Peer Review Policy

The Asian Journal of Research in Social Sciences upholds rigorous academic standards through a transparent, fair, and unbiased peer-review process. This policy outlines the principles and procedures followed to ensure the quality and integrity of all published research.


1. Type of Peer Review

AJRSS follows a double-blind peer review system, in which:

  • The identities of authors are concealed from reviewers.

  • The identities of reviewers are concealed from authors.

This approach minimizes bias and promotes impartial evaluation.


2. Initial Editorial Screening

Upon submission, each manuscript undergoes an initial assessment by the Editorial Office to ensure:

  • Relevance to the journal’s aims and scope

  • Compliance with submission guidelines

  • Originality and ethical standards

  • Basic scientific and scholarly quality

Manuscripts failing this preliminary check may be rejected without external review.


3. Reviewer Selection

Qualified reviewers are selected based on:

  • Expertise in the subject area

  • Research experience and publication record

  • Absence of conflict of interest

  • Ability to provide a constructive and timely review

The journal maintains a diverse pool of national and international reviewers to ensure balanced and informed evaluations.


4. Review Process

Each manuscript is typically evaluated by two independent reviewers. In cases of conflicting reviews, the editor may:

  • Seek a third review, or

  • Make a decision based on the journal’s editorial judgment.

Reviewers assess manuscripts for:

  • Originality and contribution to the field

  • Theoretical framework and methodology

  • Clarity, coherence, and structure

  • Validity of findings and interpretations

  • Adherence to ethical standards

  • Relevance to the journal’s scope


5. Confidentiality

All manuscripts and review comments are treated as confidential documents. Reviewers may not:

  • Share manuscripts with others

  • Use unpublished information for personal advantage

  • Reveal their identities to authors

The editorial team strictly enforces confidentiality throughout the review process.


6. Reviewer Guidelines

Reviewers are expected to:

  • Provide objective, constructive, and respectful feedback

  • Highlight strengths and weaknesses

  • Suggest improvements where needed

  • Avoid personal criticism

  • Declare any conflicts of interest immediately

  • Submit their evaluations within the allotted time


7. Possible Editorial Decisions

Based on reviewer reports and editorial assessment, the following decisions may be made:

  • Accept as submitted

  • Accept with minor revisions

  • Revise and resubmit (major revisions)

  • Reject

Authors will receive a clear explanation of the decision along with reviewer comments.


8. Revision Process

If revisions are required:

  • Authors must address all reviewer comments systematically.

  • A detailed response-to-reviewers document must be submitted.

  • Revised manuscripts may be re-evaluated by the original reviewers or editorial team.


9. Appeals and Complaints

Authors may appeal editorial decisions if they believe:

  • The review contained factual errors

  • There was evidence of bias

  • A critical aspect of the manuscript was misunderstood

Appeals must be submitted with a clear and reasoned justification. The Editor-in-Chief will review the appeal or may assign an independent reviewer.


10. Ethical Considerations

AJRSS adheres to the ethical guidelines of COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics). The journal takes strong action against:

  • Plagiarism

  • Data fabrication or falsification

  • Conflict of interest violations

  • Unethical research practices

Reviewers and authors are expected to follow the highest ethical standards.


11. Transparency and Integrity

AJRSS may publish reviewer acknowledgments annually but will never disclose individual review reports or reviewer identities.


12. Policy Review

The peer review policy is reviewed periodically to ensure alignment with international best practices in scholarly publishing.